Updated October 14, 2026 · ThriveCue Editorial Team
Top meal replacement shakes compared in the United States
We earn a commission when you sign up through links on this site. Partner status can affect where a brand appears in our rankings. How we rank
| # | Brand | Score | Key facts | Actions |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |  i-SupplementsTop pick | Not rated |
| ReviewCompareVisit |
| 2 |  HerbsPro First Order, 15% Off on Mobile App: 15% off first order | 9.0/10 |
| ReviewCompareVisit |
| 3 | MaximumSlim | 9.1/10 |
| ReviewCompareVisit |
| 4 |  ShakePlease Save $15 on your first smoothie order: $15 off first order | 8.9/10 |
| ReviewCompareVisit |
| 5 |  Legion Save 50% and free shipping on first order: 50% off plus free shipping on first order | 8.8/10 |
| ReviewCompareVisit |
| 6 |  Diet Direct Diet Direct sells meal replacement drinks, shakes, bars and snacks. | Not rated | ReviewCompareVisit | |
| 7 |  Drink Koia Koia sells plant-based protein drinks that are low in sugar and contain fiber. | Not rated |
| ReviewCompareVisit |
| 8 | Nutrisystem Nutrisystem is an online retailer at nutrisystem.com selling weight loss meal plans and shakes. | Not rated |
| ReviewCompareVisit |
| 9 |  Biocare US nutrition brand making protein shakes, bars and entrees, with 30g of protein and 26 vitamins and minerals per shake. | Not rated |
| ReviewCompareVisit |
| 10 |  Wellina Dietitian-designed breakfasts, entrees, snacks, shakes and bars, sold individually and as High Protein or Weight Loss meal bundles. | Not rated |
| ReviewCompareVisit |
Browse by category
- Online doctors and telehealth in the United States
- Online pharmacies in the United States
- Weight loss programs in the United States
- Hair loss treatments in the United States
- Online therapy in the United States
- Vitamins and multivitamins in the United States
- Gut health, greens and collagen in the United States
- Sleep and stress supplements in the United States
- Protein powders in the United States
- Creatine, pre-workout and electrolytes in the United States
- Treadmills in the United States
- Exercise bikes and rowers in the United States
- Home gym and strength equipment in the United States
- Massage guns and recovery in the United States
- Smartwatches and fitness trackers in the United States
- Smart rings in the United States
- Running shoes in the United States
- Trail running and hiking shoes in the United States
- Camping and hiking gear in the United States
- Golf equipment in the United States
- Tennis, padel and pickleball in the United States
- Activewear and gym clothing in the United States
- Sports and outdoor stores in the United States
- Hearing aids in the United States
- Glucose and blood pressure monitors in the United States
- Brain training apps in the United States
- Mobility aids in the United States
- Anti-snoring devices in the United States
- Clear aligners in the United States
- DNA and ancestry tests in the United States
- Fitness and yoga apps in the United States
- Boating and water safety gear in the United States
- Energy and focus drinks in the United States
- Medical alert systems in the United States
- Horse riding gear in the United States
- Cycling gear, parts and bike shops in the United States
- At-home health and blood tests in the United States
- Insoles, braces and supports in the United States
- Ayurvedic and herbal supplements in the United States
- Medical and incontinence supplies in the United States
- Wellness devices in the United States
- Paddle boards, diving and water sports gear in the United States
- Sleep aids and sleep tech in the United States
- Team sports equipment in the United States
- Martial arts gear in the United States
- Hunting and archery gear in the United States
- Knives and multitools in the United States
- Fishing gear in the United States
- Shooting and firearm accessories in the United States